您现在的位置: 首页 > 网站导航收录 > 百科知识百科知识
如何正确对待SCI论文退稿情况?
论文,期刊,自己的如何正确对待SCI论文退稿情况?
发布时间:2020-12-06加入收藏来源:互联网点击:
insights into the mechanism of alternans and the role of the SR, if any, in embryonic mouse ventricle. The reviewers felt that substantial new experiments would be required to address these issues.Given the nature of these concernS, the editors do not encourage revision Nevertheless, if you feel you can effectively ad dress the reviewers concerns, we would be willing to evaluate a revised version on a de novo basis. The paper would be reviewed again, with no guarantee of acceptance.Despite our decision, we wish to thank you for having submitted this manu to××××.
Very truly yours,
Name and Title
读完此信,就完全可以了解这是一封退稿信,但与完全性退稿信又有差别,这就是第二类退稿。一般而言,第二类退稿是文章尚包含某些有用的数据和信息,主编拒绝这类文章是由于数据或分析有严重缺陷( There is the type of manu that contains some useful data but the data are seriously flawed. The editor would probably reconsider such a manu if it were considera bly revised and resubmitted, but the editor does not recommend resubmission.)。对这类文章,作者不要急于修改,等找到更广泛的证据支持或有了更明晰的结论后,再进行较为全面而彻底的修订。把焕然一新的文章寄给同一杂志,主编通常是会考虑重新受理这类文章的。当然也不排斥把新修改的论文投到另一个目标杂志,如果作者经过认真考虑的话。
如何应对第三类退稿
第三类退稿是基本上可以接收,但有时可能需要追加一些试验。某些杂志使用“Reject-Resubmission Encouraged”,也许更能说明第三类退稿的含义。遇到这种情况,首先要认真阅读编辑部来函,并上网找到退稿原因,以及需求追加实验的具体内容。而后详细考虑规划下一步的实验工作,力争用最简单而有效的方法,在尽可能短的时间内完成。最后按编辑部及审稿人的要求修改论文。一般来说,这是应对第三类退稿的最佳选择。考虑新的目标杂志是不适宜的,因为第三类退稿在该杂志发表的可能性很大,没有必要“重打鼓另开张”。以下是第三类的退稿信,请比较与前两封退稿信的差别。
Dear Dr.Author,
A Reviewing Editor and two Expert Referees have assessed your paper, and I regret to say that, on balance, it is not considered suitable for publication in the ×××× In its present form. The reasons for this are set out in the3 reports which can be
found at×××××( journal website).Although we could give no guarantee of ultimate acceptance at this stage, the Journal would be prepared to consider a resubmission of the work, provided the authors are able to satisfactorrily address all of the concerns raised Such a resubmission would be given a new manu number and date of receipt, but the same reviewers would be involved, wherever possible. Please, therefore, include a point-by-point response to each of the reports, should you decide to resubmit.
Yours sincerely,
Name and Title
语言不过关被拒?美辑编译-sci论文一站式服务!
回答于 2019-09-11 08:43:50
谢邀,就在两个小时前,我有一篇文章被拒稿啦,一个大修,一个中修,但编辑没有给修改机会。拒稿后肯定是不开心的,这个毋庸置疑,但是得分情况,我目前是一名研三的学生,之前已经有三篇sci被接受,其中包括一篇Top,,对一个硕士够啦,所以拒稿后的难受也就一丢丢因为对我没有太大的影响啦!但是对于好多学生就很麻烦啦,因为这个关系到他们的奖学金,毕业,读博等一系列的事情,着急是肯定的,而且在这种情况下,很容易对自己之前的努力产生怀疑。我第一篇Sci,也开始被拒啦,我一度怀疑我以后还要不要走读博这条路。这里我要说的是,真的不要放弃,认真按审稿人意见修改,转投其他杂志,一定要找到合适的,祝各位好运,努力不会白费
上一篇:沛纳海可以和劳力士抗衡吗?
下一篇:返回列表
相关链接 |
||
网友回复(共有 0 条回复) |